Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) turns a raw, next-word-predicting language model into an assistant that follows instructions and reflects human preferences. It does so through three sequential stages: supervised fine-tuning on human-written demonstrations, training a reward model on human preference rankings, and finally optimizing the language model with a reinforcement learning algorithm, most commonly Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO). This article walks through each stage, showing which model is trained, on which data, and where the process can go wrong.

Introduction to RLHF: Aligning AI With Human Intent

RLHF is prominent in natural language understanding but is also used across other generative AI applications, as Amazon Web Services explains. Models can be trained on pre-generated human data, but adding human feedback loops significantly enhances model performance compared to its initial state—for instance, producing translations that sound natural rather than merely technically correct.

The deeper motivation, as IBM notes, is that some goals resist algorithmic definition: it would be impractical or even impossible to define "funny" in mathematical terms, but easy for humans to rate jokes generated by a large language model. That human feedback, distilled into a reward function, can then be used to improve the model's joke-writing ability. RLHF's roots trace to a 2017 paper by OpenAI's Paul F. Christiano and colleagues from OpenAI and DeepMind, which detailed success in training models for Atari games and simulated robotic locomotion.

AI companies and researchers often claim that RLHF fine-tuning ensures that the language models they market conform to human values—responding in ways that are "helpful," "harmless," and "honest," the so-called 3Hs, as a critique paper on arXiv observes. The sections below explain how the standard pipeline actually pursues that goal.

Stage 1: Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) for Instruction Following

The process begins with data collection: humans interact with the language model and provide demonstrations of ideal responses to various prompts, and this feedback is used to create a high-quality dataset of prompt-response pairs. The language model is then trained with supervised fine-tuning on this data, allowing it to learn and mimic human-like answers as a strong starting point, in the words of Weights & Biases's overview.

The purpose of this stage is format as much as content. As IBM explains, pre-training optimizes models for completion—predicting the next words in a sequence—by replicating linguistic patterns learned during pre-training. Sometimes a model will complete a sequence in a way a user doesn't want: given the prompt "teach me how to make a resumé," the model might respond "using Microsoft Word," a valid completion but one that misses the user's actual goal.

Hugging Face's technical blog by Nathan Lambert and colleagues frames the same point structurally: RLHF is challenging because it involves a multiple-model training process with different deployment stages, but the training breaks into three core steps—starting from a language model already pretrained with classical pretraining objectives. Supervised fine-tuning primes the model for instruction-following before any explicit reinforcement learning begins. This stage also matters for later training quality, because it's the SFT model that generates the candidate responses humans will rank in the next stage.